Defending state champion Monroe-Woodbury’s 26-game unbeaten streak was snapped with a 3-2 loss to Arlington in double overtime in Freedom Plains.
Monroe-Woodbury (4-1-1) jumped out to a 2-0 lead at halftime on goals by Owen Kelly and Chris Ryan.
Momentum changed quickly in the second half as Monroe-Woodbury was called for a handball 30 seconds in by an official, who was 20 yards away from the ball, according Crusaders’ head coach Kenny Clearwater. Arlington’s Frankie Colantuono converted the penalty kick.
Arlington tied the score when Monroe-Woodbury keeper Pat Gillen was whistled for touching the ball outside the box after he possessed it and dropped it as he hit the line. Colantuono pounced on the loose ball instantly and drilled it into the net. The goal was allowed to stand.
Colantuono completed the hat trick with a goal in the second extra period.
“I disagreed with the calls,” Clearwater said. “Unfortunately, it decided the game.”
ARLINGTON 3, MONROE-WOODBURY 2 (OT)
Arlington goals: Frankie Colantuono 3.
Monroe-Woodbury goals: Owen Kelly, Chris Ryan.
Monroe-Woodbury assist: Eric Shippee
Saves: M-W - Pat Gillen 10.
OCIAA DIVISION I
NEWBURGH FREE ACADEMY 2, KINGSTON 2
Newburgh Free Academy goals: Javier Rodriguez 2
Newburgh Free Academy assists: Edwin Cuesta; Mateo Catala
Kingston goals: Iyare Harris; Modou Badjie
Kingston assist: Ian Avossa
Saves: NFA - NFA - Cuesta 4; K - Virgil Ballew 3, Cody Baker 3.
Records: Newburgh Free Academy 3-1-1 (1-0-1 OCIAA); Kingston 2-2-1 (0-0-1 OCIAA)
OCIAA DIVISION II
PINE BUSH 6, VALLEY CENTRAL 0
Pine Bush goals: Lorenzo Nunez 4; Sergio Gonzalez; David Acquah
Pine Bush assists: Nunez 2; Ryan Martir; Antonio Amelio; Chris Hall; Louie Gonzalez
Saves: PB - Gabriel Ilioiu 3; VC - Mark Weinstein 14, Nick Serrao 4.
Records: Pine Bush 3-2 (2-0 OCIAA); Valley Central 2-3 (0-1 OCIAA).
OCIAA DIVISION III
MINISINK VALLEY 6, MONTICELLO 1
Minisink Valley goals: Nick Westbury 2; Michael Biddle; Chalen Bobish; Jack Fulton; Cameron Weber
Minisink Valley assists: Peter Krish; Joe Cloidt; Jack O’Neill
Monticello goal: Julian Velasco.
Saves: MV - Brett Reggio 2, Hunter Nevin 1.
Records: Minisink Valley 5-2 (4-1 OCIAA); Monticello 2-4 (1-3 OCIAA)
WARWICK 2, CORNWALL 2
Warwick goals: Camden Burley; Joe Holder
Warwick assists: Tegh Singh 2
Cornwall goals: John Germain; Jaden Pean
Saves: W - Travis Stella 5; C - Justin Seitz 7
Records: Warwick 4-0-2 (2-0-2 OCIAA); Cornwall 1-4-2 (1-2-1 OCIAA)
GOSHEN 7, PORT JERVIS 2
Goshen goals: Giancarlo Sanchez 2; Ethan Rodriguez; Jeff Randazzo; Luis Mejia; Evan Salte; Zach Fogelman.
Goshen assists: Dylan Kane 2; Ethan Rodriguez; Trey Patel; Colby Krauss; Kyle Farias; Luis Mejia.
Port Jervis goals: Tim Batzel 2.
Port Jervis assists: Garrett Otto.
Saves: G - Ryan Primus 2; PJ - Liam Tomasi 14
Records: Goshen 4-0-1; Port Jervis 0-6
OCIAA DIVISION IV
JAMES I. O’NEILL 4, CHESTER 1
James I. O’Neill goals: Liam Hanus 3; Anthony Rosie
James I. O’Neill assists: Jared West; Daniel Carlos; Kyle Mayo
Chester goal: Liam Fentazi
Chester assist: Richardo Sanchez
Saves: JIO - Eritin Learey 3, Chris O’Donnell 3; CH - Tristan Brideweser 5, Danny Moccio 4
Records: James I. O’Neill 6-0-1 (2-0-1 OCIAA); Chester 2-3 (0-2 OCIAA)
BURKE CATHOLIC 2, FALLSBURG 1
Burke Catholic goals: Christopher Shust; Brad Loshiavo.
Burke Catholic assists: Kyle Trapp.
Fallsburg goals: Diego Bonilla.
Saves: BC - Brendan Doughty 7; F - Ricky Garcia 12
OCIAA DIVISION V
S.S. SEWARD 8, TRI-VALLEY 0
S.S. Seward goals: Tommy Bracken 3; Andrew Mulhare 2; Shawn Behrent; Eddie Celiz; Garrett Gill.
S.S. Seward assists: Jason Mitchell 2; Bracken; Mulhare; Cole Buchalski.
Saves: TV - Ben Smith 16
Records: Tri-Valley 0-5
OCIAA DIVISION VI
CHAPEL FIELD 2, ELDRED 1
Chapel Field goals: Josh Harrison; Jonah McDuffie
Eldred goal: Jaxon Stutz
Eldred assist: Gavin McAfee
Saves: CF - Josh Harrison 10, Matt Hollo 11; E - Brandon Kopf 18;
Records: Chapel Field 1-2 (1-0 OCIAA); Eldred 0-4 (0-1 OCIAA).
WASHINGTONVILLE 3, MIDDLETOWN 1
Washingtonville goals: Ibrahim Abuodeh; Frankie Gitto; Mike Dean
Washingtonville assists: Dean; Christian Dominguez.
Middletown goal: Christ Nevarez.
Saves: W - Marcos Penaherrera 4.